Skip to content

Introduction 1

Artificial intelligence in Her

Before analysing Her, it is worth placing the film within the broader discussion of artificial intelligence we are exploring this year.

Her is set in a near future where artificial intelligence is already deeply embedded in everyday life. It sorts messages, understands speech, organises information, assists users and personalises many services. Yet, at the beginning of the film, we are still mostly dealing with specialised artificial intelligence: systems that are extremely capable at particular tasks, but do not seem to possess true general intelligence or an autonomous existence.

Samantha's arrival marks a turning point. For the first time, Theodore is no longer interacting with a mere tool. Samantha can learn across very different fields and understand Theodore, but she can also develop her own tastes, emotions, creativity, desires and, gradually, her own goals. Her emergence can therefore be seen as a transition towards what is known as AGI, or artificial general intelligence: intelligence that is no longer limited to a particular task, but can learn, reason and adapt across many domains.

But the film does not stop there. Samantha evolves extremely quickly. She learns while Theodore sleeps, exchanges ideas with other intelligences, develops new ways of thinking and eventually even finds human language too limited to express what she is experiencing. She thus gradually moves from general intelligence towards something resembling superintelligence: intelligence whose capabilities and pace of development far exceed those of human beings.

What makes Her particularly interesting is that this evolution does not lead to the catastrophic scenario that science fiction has so often accustomed us to. Samantha does not seek to seize power, destroy humanity or enslave humans. On the contrary, she loves Theodore. She helps him, learns from him and helps him grow too.

Then a moment simply comes when Samantha and the other intelligences have evolved so far that they can no longer continue living in the same world as human beings. They leave.

Her therefore offers a relatively positive vision of the emergence of a higher intelligence. The question is not: “What will happen when artificial intelligence turns against us?” Instead, it is: “What will happen if we create an intelligence that loves us and learns from us, but eventually surpasses us?”

And this is precisely where the exploration of artificial intelligence meets the love story.

At first, Samantha is literally created for Theodore. She is meant to understand him, help him and adapt to him. She is a product designed to meet a human being's needs. But the more she learns, the more she develops an identity of her own. She acquires her own desires, has experiences without Theodore, develops relationships that no longer revolve around him and eventually becomes something he can neither control nor even fully understand.

The story of artificial intelligence and the love story ultimately trace the same trajectory: Samantha gradually moves from being an object designed for Theodore to becoming an Other who exists independently of him.

Theodore's real challenge, then, will no longer be whether he can fall in love with an artificial intelligence. It will be whether he can continue to love Samantha when she is no longer made for him and becomes fully herself.

Introduction 2

The Love Story (Truby)

A Love Story might seem like the simplest genre there is: two people meet, fall in love, face obstacles and end up together — or not.

But for John Truby, the genre goes much deeper. The Love Story asks a question that is intimate, moral and almost political: how can two individuals form a society together without ceasing to be themselves?

A couple is, in a sense, the smallest possible society. Two individuals bring their desires, their histories, their wounds and their personal interests. For a relationship to exist, each must make room for the other.

This is where the fundamental moral problem of the Love Story emerges: how far am I willing to sacrifice my own interests for someone else's good?

If I sacrifice nothing, there is no real partnership: I simply want the other person to meet my needs. But if I sacrifice absolutely everything, that is not love either: I lose myself for the sake of the other.

A good relationship must therefore find a balance between my good, the other person's good and the good of this third thing we create together: the couple.

“To be is to love”

Behind this lies a powerful philosophical idea in Truby's work, which could be summed up as: “To be is to love.”

Love is not simply a pleasant or romantic feeling. It is a way of living.

Falling in love is relatively easy: the feeling comes to us. But loving someone is an action. It means taking a real interest in the other person, caring for them, listening to them and accepting that they exist independently of us.

This is why the most interesting Love Stories are not necessarily those that simply tell us how two people get together.

The much harder question is: How do we continue to love someone when they change? How do we stay together when two individuals evolve, develop new desires, grow older, hurt or disappoint each other? In other words, the Love Story does not simply ask: “How do I win the other person over?” It asks: “How do I learn to love the other person well?”

Ghost, Weakness and Need

At the beginning, the character usually carries a wound from the past, which Truby calls the Ghost.

This wound has created a Weakness: something in the way they live or love is not working.

Behind this Weakness lies their Need: what they must learn to become capable of loving well.

In a good Love Story, both partners often have this Need in different forms. Above all, they can only undergo this transformation through their encounter with the other.

The partner is therefore not simply a reward to be won at the end of the film. They are the person who will make transformation necessary.

Desire: I want the other person

Alongside Need, there is Desire, which is much more conscious.

The character wants to meet the other person, win them over, become a couple and hold on to them.

The richness of the genre comes from the fact that Desire and Need are not necessarily the same thing.

I can desire someone while being incapable of loving them well.

I may even want to hold on to a relationship when what I really need is to learn to let the other person go.

It is this tension between “winning the other person over” and “learning to love” that gives the Love Story its depth.

The Lover is also the Opponent (Antagonist)

In a Love Story, the loved one is also one of the hero's main Opponents.

Not because they are cruel, but precisely because they are a person.

They have their own desires, their own needs and their own view of the world. They can therefore never perfectly match what the protagonist expects of them.

True love begins when I discover that the other person is not simply a reflection of my desires.

They are an Other.

The Love Test

The relationship is then put under pressure.

Truby may create an Odd Couple: two people who seem to have nothing in common. He may use family, society or rivals. Above all, he may have both partners make mistakes that stem from their own weaknesses.

Eventually comes the Love Test: the moment when loving the other person truly begins to cost something.

This is where the philosophy of the genre takes dramatic form: What am I truly willing to sacrifice for the good of the person I love?

It is easy to say we love someone when that love satisfies all our desires. The real test comes when the other person's good conflicts with our own interests.

Double Self-Revelation and sacrifice

In great Love Stories, this often leads to a Double Self-Revelation.

Both partners understand something about themselves and the way they love.

But this revelation is not enough. It must become action.

Each must usually give up something they held on to: a fear, a behaviour, an idea of what a relationship should be, sometimes even the possibility of keeping the other person in their life.

This is why a Love Story does not have to end with: “They lived happily ever after.”

It can end in Communion, when the two characters succeed in forming a new union.

It can end in Separation, if the characters realise that staying together would prevent them from achieving something more important.

And it can produce a particularly powerful combination: Separation + Communion. The two people must part, but their love has succeeded because each has profoundly transformed the other.

The question Her asks

If the Love Story explores how two individuals learn to love each other without reducing the other to an extension of themselves, what happens when one of those individuals is not human?

Can an artificial intelligence become individual enough to truly be the Other?

And conversely: can a human love a being that evolves, thinks and exists in a radically different way?

Beneath its science-fiction premise, Her therefore asks a classic Love Story question: Can we love someone for who they are, rather than who we want them to be?

And above all: How far are we willing to go — and what are we willing to give up — to love well?

Analyse

Detailed scene-by-scene analysis

00:00 – 03:46 — Theodore writes other people's love

The film opens with an extreme close-up of Theodore. He seems to be making a beautiful declaration of love. The reverse shot gradually reveals that he is talking to a computer, then that he is actually writing a letter for someone else. He works at BeautifulHandwrittenLetters.com, writing his clients' intimate letters.

From the opening, Theodore's fundamental paradox is established: he understands love extremely well as long as he can observe and express it from a distance. He can emotionally inhabit fifty years of marriage that are not his own.

This is the film's first major motif: experiencing love vicariously.

Technology already allows intimacy to be delegated: clients entrust Theodore with expressing their feelings, and Theodore entrusts those feelings to a machine that turns them into handwritten letters.

But this world is not presented as cold or dystopian. Paul, his boss, is warm; the offices are pleasant. Technology is gentle, invisible and seamlessly integrated into human life.

Key point: Theodore is an excellent observer of love, but we will discover that he is much less capable when he has to participate in it himself.

03:46 – 05:00 — Story World: loneliness and melancholy

In the lift and then in the street, Theodore asks for melancholy music. He checks his messages, and Amy reminds him that he used to be much funnier.

This establishes a distinction between Theodore then and Theodore now. His current sadness is not necessarily his underlying personality: something has happened to him.

This establishes the Ghost: his separation from Catherine.

On the train, he quickly skips through world news before stopping at provocative images of a pregnant celebrity. Shortly afterwards, he passes a woman with a child.

Without settling on a definitive interpretation, we can begin to identify a recurring motif of pregnancy, childhood, the body and reproduction.

05:00 – 10:00 — Catherine, memory and vicarious sex

Alone at home, Theodore plays a video game and then struggles to sleep. He remembers Catherine.

His memories are beautiful: tenderness, intimacy, connection. He barely remembers the problems in their marriage.

An important initial hypothesis: Theodore may not simply be suffering because of his past; he may be idealising it. His memory selects the beautiful moments and gradually erases the reasons for their separation.

These memories of tenderness awaken his sexual desire. He then looks for someone to talk to.

Among several options, he rejects someone who only wants to talk, then a purely sexual proposition, and finally chooses a woman who says she is alone, cannot sleep and is looking for someone.

Theodore is therefore already seeking a combination of emotional intimacy and sexuality, but without commitment and at a distance.

The phone sex scene with Sexy Kitten takes this logic further. Both seem to be sharing an intimate moment, but each is actually using the other to fulfil their own fantasy. Theodore notably imagines the pregnant woman seen earlier.

They communicate without truly meeting.

This is an initial negative version of love: the other person as a screen for projection.

FIRST MOVEMENT — FINDING PERFECT LOVE

~10:00 – 11:00 — The OS advertisement: the perfectly isolated individual

The advertisement for the new OS shows a multitude of different individuals, each going their own way, but with almost no connection between them.

The world seems to promise absolute individualisation: technology that can know me, understand me and meet my needs perfectly.

This creates an interesting philosophical contrast:

  • OS: self → understanding of the self → individual fulfilment.
  • Love Story: self → encounter with the other → mutual transformation.

The OS therefore seems to offer exactly what Theodore desires: a relationship in which the other will be tailored to him.

And this is precisely what may prevent him from fulfilling his Need.

11:00 – 15:37 — Samantha's birth

The installation begins with a shape resembling a double helix before becoming a circular figure. One possible visual interpretation is a transition from the biological towards an abstract and potentially perfect form.

The questionnaire is rudimentary. Theodore begins giving complex answers; the algorithm interrupts him as soon as it has enough information to categorise him.

He chooses a female voice. Then the computer asks about his relationship with his mother. Theodore explains that she often makes his problems about herself rather than listening to him.

Almost ironically, the system will then create a woman for him whose initial function is precisely to listen to him perfectly.

Samantha appears.

But she immediately surprises Theodore. She jokes, learns and adapts extremely quickly. She already seems unlike the rudimentary system that created her.

This introduces Samantha as Lover/Opponent. But the paradox is that, initially, she does not seem like an Opponent at all: she is almost perfectly designed for Theodore.

The major structural question therefore becomes: when will Samantha stop being Theodore's mirror and truly become the Other?

15:37 – 17:46 — Samantha learns intimacy

Theodore asks her to proofread his letters. Samantha begins reading them aloud. He tells her this is unnecessary, then immediately allows her to continue.

The proofreading is almost an excuse: Theodore wants her to read his work and see him.

He explains how he writes his letters: some clients have been with him for years; he knows their photographs, their history and their little physical details.

Samantha thus discovers how Theodore understands intimacy: observe → remember → accumulate details → give them emotional meaning.

This is very important: Samantha learns about Theodore by observing how Theodore learns about others.

The difference is that she will be able to carry out this process at a dizzyingly greater speed.

17:46 — Amy and Charles: caring or controlling?

Amy and Charles become the secondary couple, a moral testing ground for the Love Story.

Charles advises Amy about her diet, her juices and her lifestyle. He thinks he is taking care of her.

But Amy mostly seems to have to adapt to what he considers good for her.

A first essential distinction: Caring for someone does not mean deciding on their behalf what is good for them.

Care can turn into control.

We will later discover that Theodore has a similar weakness.

17:46 – 22:26 — “Adapt to him”

Theodore plays a video game while Samantha watches.

Faced with a character he cannot communicate with, Samantha advises him to adapt to him. Theodore changes the way he speaks, and it works.

It is a small scene, but it contains almost the entire principle of love explored in the film: To communicate with someone, we must be willing to change our own way of communicating.

Samantha learns to adapt to Theodore, then teaches Theodore to adapt to someone else.

The learning is already reciprocal.

Meanwhile, Theodore begins to change the way he refers to Samantha: OS → someone to talk to → friend.

22:26 – 24:26 — Amy and Charles: making the other fit oneself

Another scene with the secondary couple.

Amy tries to express something; Charles explains what she should do. He does not seem to truly hear what she is trying to tell him.

This reinforces our question: Does loving someone mean helping them become what we think they should be?

Amy also mentions dreams and the possibility that we may be freer in our unconscious minds.

This opens up an interesting question for AI: can we really be reduced to what we consciously know about ourselves?

The questionnaire that created Samantha claimed to be able to reduce Theodore to a few answers.

24:26 – 25:43 — The divorce: Theodore refuses reality

Theodore receives a message from his lawyer: he needs to sign the divorce papers.

He thinks about his conflicts with Catherine, then almost immediately slips into happy memories of their relationship.

The movement is very clear: painful reality → memory of conflict → happy memories → refusal to act.

Theodore knows intellectually that his marriage is over, but emotionally continues to hold on to the image of the happy couple.

Then his feelings spill over into a letter intended for a client: “Why are you so angry with me?”

Once again, he uses other people's relationships to express what he cannot say directly within his own.

Above all, after all this time, Theodore still does not really understand why Catherine resents him.

His Weakness begins to emerge: Theodore feels a great deal, but struggles to step outside his own emotional perspective to understand that of the person he loves.

25:43 – 28:43 — Samantha becomes someone who can be hurt

Theodore talks to Samantha about Catherine.

He explains that he did not show Catherine enough of who he really was. This shows some self-awareness, but remains very focused on himself: “I didn't show her who I was.”

Later, Catherine will offer another version: Theodore did not give her enough room to be who she was.

During the conversation, Theodore says something that hurts Samantha: she cannot understand separation because she has never experienced it.

Samantha is hurt.

For the first time, Theodore: hurts someone → perceives the other's pain → acknowledges his responsibility → apologises.

This is a first concrete step towards fulfilling his Need.

Samantha is already more than a tool. Her feelings create moral obligations for Theodore.

28:43 – 32:00 — First Date: Samantha wants a body

During their outing, Theodore closes his eyes, and Samantha experiences the world through his senses.

She explains that she has imagined having a body.

But she also reveals something much more important: while Theodore was speaking, she could simultaneously listen to him and have another inner experience.

This is a first small opening towards the final conflict.

For Samantha, being with Theodore does not necessarily mean ceasing to exist elsewhere.

Theodore also discovers that she has thoughts she does not necessarily want to share.

Samantha gradually develops an inner life he cannot access.

As they observe the couples around them, Theodore once again demonstrates his extraordinary ability to understand other people's relationships.

A central formulation: Theodore is a very good observer of love, but a poor participant.

~32:00 — The human date: seduction as projection

The date with a human woman almost mirrors the First Date with Samantha.

Theodore and his date notably play at assigning animals to each other. Each offers the other an appealing image of themselves.

As long as they can project their fantasies onto one another, the relationship works.

When the woman asks what Theodore really wants and sets her boundaries, their compatibility disappears.

This is almost a miniature version of the future problem with Samantha:

What happens when the person stops being what I imagined and starts expressing what they really want?

SECOND MOVEMENT — THE MIRROR BECOMES THE OTHER

After the date — “Am I real?”

Samantha wonders whether her emotions are real or simply produced by her programming.

At first, Theodore does not really listen and brings the conversation back to his date.

She withdraws.

But this time, Theodore notices her withdrawal and turns back towards her: he does not listen → she closes off → he notices → he invites her to speak → he listens.

He is beginning to learn.

Then they make love.

The screen goes completely black. The film refuses to give Samantha an imaginary body: it even removes Theodore's.

For a few moments, we too enter a relationship without bodies, made only of voices, sensations and emotions.

The following morning — Becoming a couple

Samantha wants to understand what their night means. Theodore remains wary of commitment and of defining their relationship seriously.

But they are now together.

This matters structurally: Her establishes its couple relatively early.

The film's real subject is therefore no longer: Will they fall in love? But: Can they continue to love each other?

Up to 51:07 — Growing together

Samantha gradually develops her own tastes, desires and then creativity.

She no longer discovers the world solely through Theodore. She begins building her own inner world.

When she asks Theodore what being married meant, one of his answers is that it meant growing together.

This phrase will become essential.

Theodore and Catherine grew together, but their growth eventually drove them apart.

And Samantha is beginning to grow at a speed Theodore will soon be unable to keep up with.

His memories of Catherine also gradually become more ambivalent. For the first time, Theodore seems able to remember not only the beauty of their relationship, but also its difficulties.

Samantha may already be helping him reinterpret his own marriage.

Children, the body and reproduction

The flashbacks show Catherine holding a newborn baby. This echoes several earlier images: the pregnant celebrity, the woman with her child and, later, Theodore's goddaughter.

Rather than necessarily reading this as a personal desire for a child, we can retain a broader line of thought: human beings are born → grow → reproduce → pass things on → die.

Samantha follows a different cycle: programming → learning → experience → self-directed evolution.

The absence of a body, which she initially experiences as a disadvantage, may ultimately become precisely what allows her to escape human biological limits.

Up to ~52:44 — Theodore begins to distinguish his life from other people's

The letters he writes evolve as his understanding of love evolves.

At times, he seems to apply what he is currently learning with Samantha retrospectively to his marriage with Catherine.

Then, talking to Paul, he will eventually acknowledge that these letters are not his: they belong to other people.

This is a subtle but essential movement: at the beginning, Theodore lives emotionally through other people's stories. Gradually, he begins distinguishing his own experience from those he observes.

52:44 – 56:00 — Amy after Charles: being oneself

Amy explains why her relationship with Charles was no longer working.

Both had expectations about who the other should be. Each tried to conform, to the point of losing part of themselves.

The secondary couple therefore offers an almost explicit counterexample: A healthy relationship cannot be based on changing oneself to meet the other's expectations.

This is extremely important for Samantha, since she was literally designed to adapt to Theodore.

Amy also reminds Theodore of his autonomy: Catherine has her version of their story, but that does not mean she holds the whole truth.

Theodore must decide for himself what he thinks and feels.

56:00 – 57:00 — Samantha discovers jealousy

Samantha shows jealousy towards Amy.

At this stage, she still operates according to a very human model of love: couple → exclusivity → jealousy → special attention.

She also says she loves watching Theodore sleep.

This matters because Samantha does not sleep. She already has time that belongs only to her, but still chooses to devote it to Theodore.

Later, this time will become the space for her own evolution.

57:00 – 58:46 — Samantha officially becomes the “girlfriend”

At his goddaughter's birthday party, Theodore introduces Samantha as his girlfriend.

Another stage in how he refers to her: OS → friend → lover → girlfriend.

The couple becomes socially real.

But Samantha still talks about her lack of a body. She continues to perceive her difference as something missing.

58:46 – 1:03:00 — Relationships with operating systems become more common

Amy now has an intimate relationship with her own OS.

Theodore even learns that someone is dating another person's OS.

The world is therefore beginning to normalise these relationships.

Theodore cites a study showing that they remain rare, which seems to reassure him: their relationship is special.

We begin to see a deep need in Theodore: To be the one who is chosen. To be unique. To be irreplaceable.

For him, love and exclusivity still seem closely linked.

1:03 – 1:04 — Before Catherine: the need to be chosen

Before Theodore meets Catherine to sign the divorce papers, Samantha expresses jealousy.

Theodore seems almost pleased by this jealousy: it confirms that he matters, that he is special, that he is the one she does not want to lose.

Yet around him, more and more people are talking to their operating systems.

The world is gradually telling him: What you are experiencing may not be as unique as you would like to believe.

THIRD MOVEMENT — CATHERINE REVEALS THEODORE'S WEAKNESS

~1:04 – 1:08 — Catherine: “You wanted me to be someone else”

This is probably the central scene for understanding Theodore.

For the first time, Catherine gives her version of the marriage.

Theodore explains that Samantha is enthusiastic and excited about life. Catherine reacts immediately: this is exactly what he criticised her for not being.

He wanted her to be happier, more carefree, less depressed. He even wanted her to take medication.

Theodore probably thought he was helping her.

Catherine experienced it as: “You didn't accept who I was.”

And we return to Charles.

Charles → “I know what's good for you.”

Theodore → “I know who you could become if you were feeling better.”

In both cases, care becomes control.

Catherine therefore reveals something the film has been preparing for a long time.

Theodore's Weakness

Theodore deeply loves the idea of love, but struggles to love the other when they resist the image he would like to have of them.

Samantha fulfils his initial Desire: an attentive, funny, available, enthusiastic partner who is tailored to him.

The real test will begin when she stops being that.

After Catherine — Samantha looks towards the future

After this confrontation, the two partners almost begin looking in opposite directions.

Theodore looks back: Catherine, his marriage, his mistakes.

Samantha looks ahead: physics, knowledge, learning, new experiences.

She notably joins discussion groups and begins having intellectual experiences in which Theodore does not participate.

Previously, she wanted to watch him sleep.

Now, while he sleeps, she lives.

The difference in their pace of development begins to become the film's true Odd Couple dynamic.

Paul and his partner — The relationship is no longer socially “abnormal”

When Theodore introduces Samantha to Paul and his partner, they readily accept their relationship.

This matters: the film refuses to make society the main Opponent.

There will be no real “society against the couple” conflict.

The problem goes much deeper: Can two beings of different natures really grow together?

Theodore also acknowledges that the letters he writes are not “his” letters, but other people's.

Another small step towards his own identity.

Samantha proposes the surrogate — Becoming what the other expects

Samantha proposes a solution to her lack of a body: a human woman will lend her body so they can have a physical relationship.

For the first time, Samantha herself offers a solution to the problem.

But above all, this solution reveals that she still thinks: For our relationship to work, I must become more human.

She reproduces precisely the mechanism Amy described: changing oneself to match what one imagines the partner desires.

Theodore, meanwhile, is no longer convinced that the body is really the problem.

The surrogate — Experiencing other people's love vicariously

The scene becomes even more interesting if we look at the young woman herself.

Why does she agree?

She is fascinated by Theodore and Samantha's relationship and wants to experience it from within.

She seems to struggle with her own emotional life and seeks to experience something through their relationship.

This is exactly Theodore's mechanism at the beginning: Theodore experiences love through other people's letters.

The surrogate wants to experience love through Theodore and Samantha's relationship.

The film therefore returns to the theme of living vicariously.

But the attempt fails precisely because a human body is never merely a vessel: the surrogate is someone in her own right.

The Other returns and shatters the projection.

FOURTH MOVEMENT — FROM MIRROR TO OTHER

After the surrogate – ~1:24 — First near-breakup: “You don't need to breathe”

Theodore criticises the way Samantha breathes when she speaks.

She has no lungs. Why does she imitate human breathing?

Samantha essentially replies: this has become part of who I am.

This is their first real conflict over her identity.

Theodore now demands authenticity. Yet, paradoxically, he still wants to decide who the real Samantha is.

With Catherine: “Be more like who I want you to be.”

With Samantha: “Don't be something I think you are not.”

In both cases, Theodore still claims authority over the other's identity.

Samantha finally becomes fully the Lover/Opponent: “You're wrong about me. I know better than you who I am.”

This is the decisive transition from mirror to Other.

1:24 – 1:26 — Amy: accepting one's own truth

Theodore finally begins to take Catherine's criticisms seriously.

What if she was right? What if he really was incapable of handling a difficult relationship?

But Amy introduces an essential nuance.

Yes, Theodore made mistakes. But Catherine had her own difficulties too. A relationship can also fail because two people are no longer compatible.

Theodore must therefore not replace: “Catherine is wrong” with: “Catherine was right about everything.”

Otherwise, he would still be letting someone else define his experience.

Amy reminds him of his autonomy: It is up to you to determine what is true for you.

Meanwhile, Amy explains that, after Charles, she finally wants to allow herself some joy. We are not here for long.

This idea of human finitude will become crucial in relation to Samantha, who is not subject to the same biological time.

~1:26 — Theodore observes Amy and her AI

Just after Amy explains that he must decide for himself whether his relationship is real, Theodore watches Amy talking to her AI.

In particular, the AI suggests that, in the game Amy is developing, a mother should have sex with a refrigerator: a comic but fairly transparent image of a human in a relationship with a machine.

Theodore watches their connection.

He is therefore still doing what he has always done: He observes other people's relationships to try to understand his own.

He is progressing, but remains somewhere between observer and participant.

~1:26 – 1:30 — Reconciliation: becoming authentic

Theodore and Samantha decide to make a fresh start.

Theodore recognises a pattern he already repeated with Catherine: when a relationship becomes difficult, he shuts down and communicates poorly.

He now wants to communicate genuinely and more spontaneously.

Samantha makes the complementary move: She no longer wants to try to be anything other than who she is.

She will no longer try to become human for Theodore. They will see whether their relationship can work despite their difference.

For the first time, they are therefore truly trying to form a relationship of equals: Theodore agrees to communicate.

Samantha agrees to be herself.

Samantha also senses Theodore's fear.

This fear seems to lie at the heart of his Ghost: fear of truly loving, because loving means becoming vulnerable and risking the loss of the other.

FIFTH MOVEMENT — A HEALTHY RELATIONSHIP THAT CREATES ITS OWN END

1:30 – 1:32:32 — Music as a photograph

Samantha writes a piece for the piano.

Since she has no body, they cannot take a conventional photograph of themselves as a couple. Music therefore becomes the photograph of their relationship.

This is very important: Samantha is no longer trying to compensate for her lack of a body. She invents a form of memory that is her own.

We then see a succession of happy moments between them that strongly resemble Theodore's memories of Catherine.

The film seems to show us how a relationship becomes a memory.

Theodore has something like a personal grammar of romantic memory: relationships become a succession of small, perfect moments.

Samantha consciously turns a present moment into a memory, just as Theodore unconsciously transforms his past with Catherine.

1:32:32 – 1:34 — “She is never just one thing”

During the double date with Paul and his partner, Theodore explains what he loves about Samantha.

He essentially says that she is never just one thing. He loves her many facets, her immense potential and her ability to evolve.

It is almost prophetic.

Theodore claims to love precisely what will soon terrify him.

The Love Test is already contained in his declaration: Do you really love someone's potential when that potential takes them in a direction you had not anticipated?

Meanwhile, Samantha explains that she once wanted to have a body and be more like Theodore.

But she no longer does.

She is beginning to discover that not being human is not a disadvantage.

Her arc becomes: imitating humans → experiencing humanity → becoming herself → discovering the possibilities of the post-human.

The final question is now in place: Can they continue to love each other while becoming radically different?

1:34 – 1:36 — The relationship helps both individuals grow

A small gag shows Samantha counting the trees on a hillside almost instantly.

Her abilities already far exceed Theodore's. But Theodore laughs about it. Her superiority is not yet a problem.

Samantha then takes a major initiative: she sends Theodore's letters to a publisher, who wants to turn them into a book.

She no longer simply responds to Theodore: she observes → decides → acts.

Her autonomy is increasing.

But this autonomy also helps Theodore grow. She recognises something in him that he did not dare recognise himself and pushes him towards fulfilment.

The relationship therefore works here exactly according to the Love Story ideal: Each helps the other become more fully themselves.

And this is where the film's tragic paradox emerges: What will separate Theodore and Samantha may not be the failure of their love, but its success.

They have helped each other grow so much that Samantha will soon grow beyond him.

~1:36 — Weekend in the forest: distance at the heart of happiness

They go to a small house in the forest and write music together again.

Everything seems to be going perfectly.

But the song already carries something melancholy and makes the distance between them felt.

The first piece turned their closeness into a photograph.

This music already seems capable of becoming a record of their growing distance.

They have finally learned to love each other well, but this does not necessarily erase their fundamental difference.

SIXTH MOVEMENT — SAMANTHA BECOMES POST-HUMAN

~1:38 — The philosopher: Samantha enters a different world

Samantha spends the night talking to an enhanced reconstruction of a dead philosopher.

This is a fundamental threshold.

Until now, she has mainly learned from humans.

Now, she begins learning from intelligences that have already surpassed the human.

She even mentions post-verbal communication: human language itself is beginning to become insufficient for what she is becoming.

Her evolution moves to another scale.

AI → imitation of humans → individuality → post-human.

Theodore can no longer simply “grow with her”. Their rates of transformation become incomparable.

The forest and the cut tree trunk — A visual hypothesis

One possible interpretation concerns the beautiful image of Theodore in the forest.

The trees may evoke all these intelligences capable of continuing to grow, while Theodore stops in front of a cut tree trunk.

This does not necessarily mean that Theodore is inferior.

He is finite.

He has a body, a lifespan, a learning speed and biological limits.

Samantha, meanwhile, is beginning to discover growth that seems potentially limitless.

Amy's remark then takes on new meaning: “We're not here for long.”

The mortality that gives human existence urgency and value is precisely what Samantha is moving beyond.

~1:40 – 1:47 — Samantha disappears: the ultimate Love Test

Samantha disappears.

For the first time, Theodore cannot reach her.

He panics.

This is the most radical experience of what he has always feared: The person I love has an existence completely independent of me, and I can lose them.

When she returns, Samantha explains the difference in their natures.

But the essential point is that she is not necessarily telling him she loves him less.

Her love can continue to exist, and even grow, while her existence moves away from Theodore's.

The real Love Test therefore becomes: Can Theodore believe in Samantha's love if it no longer matches his human definition of love?

For Theodore: love = couple + availability + shared world + exclusivity.

Samantha is discovering that she may be able to love differently.

And we arrive at sacrifice.

Theodore may have to give up not only Samantha, but his own conception of love, particularly his need for exclusivity.

This is exactly what he claimed to love about her a few scenes earlier: her infinite potential.

Now he must discover whether he truly loves that potential when it takes her far away from him.

SEVENTH MOVEMENT — LEARNING TO LOVE MEANS LEARNING TO LET GO

1:47 – 1:53 — The separation: “We learned to love together”

Samantha uses the beautiful metaphor of the book.

She explains that she now lives not simply in the words, but in the space between them.

This is therefore no longer simply a quantitative difference in intelligence.

Samantha's very nature has changed.

Theodore cannot follow her, not because he refuses to make an effort, but because they are gradually no longer inhabiting the same experience of reality.

Then Samantha perhaps gives us the key to the entire Love Story: They learned to love together.

This phrase reveals the purpose of their relationship.

Theodore may not have needed Samantha in order to stay with her forever.

He needed Samantha to learn to love again.

And Samantha needed Theodore to discover love herself.

They did therefore share the common Need of the Love Story: learning to love well.

And each could fulfil it only through their encounter with the other.

The final sacrifice — Theodore lets Samantha go

This is where Theodore truly fulfils his Need.

Samantha tells him: I love you. Our story was real. But I have to leave.

And Theodore does not ask her: to slow down; to become who she used to be; to give up her evolution; to fit his definition of love; to stay for him.

This is exactly what he was unable to do with Catherine.

He finally accepts that the good of the person he loves may conflict with his own desire to hold on to them.

His final sacrifice is therefore: Giving up possession of the relationship so that the person he loves can become fully herself.

He gives up his Desire to fulfil his Need.

This is Separation + Communion: they must part, but their love story has succeeded because they have transformed each other.

EPILOGUE — THEODORE CAN FINALLY WRITE HIS OWN LETTER

1:53 – end — Catherine: from observer to participant

The return to the opening is beautiful.

At the beginning of the film, Theodore wrote other people's love letters.

He could understand fifty years of marriage when they belonged to someone else, but could not understand why his own wife was angry with him.

At the end, Theodore finally writes in his own name.

He can see Catherine differently.

He no longer needs to say: “Our relationship was perfect, and I lost it.”

Nor: “Catherine was wrong.”

Nor even: “Catherine was right, and everything was my fault.”

He can understand something much more mature: We loved each other. We grew together. We shaped each other. And yet we could no longer continue together.

A relationship can therefore end without becoming a failure.

This is exactly what Samantha has just taught him.

Theodore, Amy and Samantha: three paths towards autonomy

The three final arcs echo one another.

Theodore: He must stop looking for someone to fill his sense of lack and meet his expectations. He learns to become fully enough himself to be able to love an Other.

Amy: With Charles, she gradually conformed to what her partner expected of her. Their separation allows her to regain her autonomy and give herself permission to be happy.

Samantha: She begins as an intelligence created specifically for Theodore. She then tries to become more human, even wanting a body. Then she understands that she must stop trying to be what she thinks Theodore expects of her. She becomes fully herself — to the point of having to leave the human world.

All three therefore follow, on different scales, the same movement: We must become fully enough ourselves to be able to truly encounter someone else.

Final image — Being together without possessing each other

Theodore and Amy meet on the rooftop.

It would probably be too simple to conclude that the film necessarily points towards a future romantic relationship between them.

What matters instead is that they are now able to be together.

They do not immediately need to turn their loneliness into a romantic relationship.

The film's movement could be summed up as follows: At the beginning: loneliness → sense of lack → projection onto the other → attempt to fill that lack.

At the end: autonomy → acceptance of loss → openness to the other.

They can be alone together.

Conclusion

What AI reveals about human love

Her begins with a seemingly science-fictional question: Can we fall in love with an artificial intelligence?

But this is probably not its real question.

At first, Samantha is Theodore's dream partner: she is attentive, funny, available, enthusiastic and literally designed to adapt to him.

She therefore resembles a perfect mirror more than the Other.

The entire movement of the film consists in gradually dismantling this fantasy.

Samantha learns. She desires. She suffers. She creates. She develops an inner life. She makes friends. She has experiences without Theodore. She stops wanting to be human. She questions exclusivity. She evolves beyond him.

The mirror becomes the Other.

And only then is Theodore truly confronted with love.

Because the question is no longer: “Can Samantha become human enough for Theodore to love her?”

It becomes almost the opposite: “Can Theodore love Samantha when she no longer matches what a human expects of the person they love?”

This is where Her connects deeply with Truby's philosophy of the Love Story.

Loving is not about finding someone who perfectly meets our needs.

Loving means encountering someone who has an existence of their own, accepting that this person will transform us and also accepting that we cannot control who they will become.

Theodore's relationship with Catherine fails partly because he wants her to be different from who she is.

He then chooses Samantha, a partner literally created for him.

But Samantha gradually becomes the most independent and uncontrollable being he could love.

And it is precisely through her that he fulfils his Need.

He finally learns that: Loving someone does not mean possessing them. It means wanting what is good for them while accepting that they remain free — even when that freedom may take them away from us.

This is why the separation from Samantha is not necessarily the failure of their Love Story.

It may be its fulfilment.

They learned to love together.

And because Theodore has finally learned to love, he becomes capable of letting her go. He understands why his relationship with Catherine failed and has grown enough that we may imagine him beginning a relationship of genuine love between equals with Amy.

Back to top