Skip to content

Introduction

In my view, the primary purpose of film analysis is to understand the message the filmmaker seeks to convey through their work. This message takes the form of a reflection on a particular theme, and the filmmaker offers us, consciously or unconsciously, a perspective on how this theme can be approached in life. To decode this message, I mainly use two tools:

  • Narrative structure, which the filmmaker uses to organize and convey their ideas.
  • Film genre, which shapes the theme, tone, and overall philosophy of the story. Each genre explores specific issues.

1. Narrative Structure

Narrative structure refers to the sequence of stages or structural points through which a story unfolds. Most narratives, particularly films, follow a relatively common structure, which can be simplified as follows.

1.1 Exposition – Weakness / Need

In the exposition, the hero is introduced in their everyday life. We identify a weakness in the character: a psychological or moral trait that prevents them from being truly happy. This weakness creates a need: the need to grow and overcome this inner limitation.

Throughout the film, the character faces situations designed to make them aware of this need. If they succeed, they will learn something and become happier as a result.

1.2 Desire

An inciting incident occurs, disrupting the hero's everyday life. This event creates a concrete desire, a goal to achieve. From that point on, the character pursues this desire, and by the end of the story, we discover whether or not they achieve it.

1.3 The Antagonist

Someone or something prevents the hero from achieving their goal. The antagonist opposes the hero by creating obstacles and threatening their plan.

1.4 The Plan

The hero develops a strategy to achieve their desire, while the antagonist develops their own strategy to prevent it. This opposition structures most of the narrative.

1.5 Resolution

The hero experiences a personal revelation, often connected to their initial need. This realization leads them to make a final moral choice, which determines the outcome of the story: do they achieve their desire or not, and at what cost?

1.6 New Equilibrium

The hero returns to a transformed version of everyday life:

  • either they have achieved their desire,
  • or they have understood their need,
  • or both.


We then observe how their life has changed as a result of this transformation. These stages are deliberately simplified: narrative structure is, of course, much more complex. Nevertheless, these reference points help us understand how the filmmaker's ideas are structured and developed.

    2. Dual Narrative Structure

    To fully understand how a story works, it is essential to distinguish between two narrative lines:

    • The plot: the external line of desire (what the character wants).
    • The character arc: the internal line of need (what the character must understand or overcome).


    These two lines intertwine, influence one another, and come into conflict throughout the film.

    3. Film Genre

    Each film genre approaches this structure in its own way, depending on the themes it explores.

    3.1 The Horror Genre

    «The Shining» belongs to the horror genre. From a narrative perspective, this genre often follows a relatively simple structure:

    • A hero in their everyday life (exposition, weakness/need)
    • A supernatural or abnormal event (inciting incident)
    • A monstrous entity (antagonist)
    • The antagonist's plan: to kill the hero
    • The hero's desire: to survive
    • The hero's plan: to escape death


    The protagonist is therefore primarily reactive, and the narrative relies on an escalation of danger within a linear plot. The stakes are binary: life / death, which may seem, at first glance, less philosophical than other genres such as crime films, which question social morality (for example: is violence justified in a violent and corrupt world, as in «Batman»?).

    3.2 The Psychologization of Horror

    What becomes interesting is what the genre explores through the character's internal narrative line: their psychological arc. Edgar Allan Poe, for example, transforms the supernatural into a psychological threat, paving the way for deeper thematic reflection. Traditionally, horror explores two major themes:

    3.2.1 Humanity's Relationship with Death

    Human beings are aware of their own mortality, which is often unbearable. They therefore seek to transcend death: religion, immortality, creation, legacy… Narratively, this translates into an immediate escape from death, but psychologically, it reflects a broader exploration of the refusal to disappear.

    3.2.2 The Definition of Human Nature

    When horror takes on a psychological dimension, it questions what defines a human being. By comparing humans to monsters (dehumanized figures: beasts, robots, ghosts…), the narrative highlights what distinguishes us from them and allows us to establish a hierarchy of human values.

    3.3 Moral Escalation

    The escalation of violence and the imminence of death push the hero to their limits. Their human values are tested with increasing intensity: how far are they willing to go to survive?

    Human beings can evolve toward greater humanity… but they can also follow the opposite path and become dehumanized, growing closer to the monster. There is therefore a conflict of values between humans and monsters, and the hero is capable of embodying both.

    «Frankenstein» is an emblematic example of this reflection. While Dr. Frankenstein seeks to transcend death by creating life, he becomes increasingly monstrous as he loses his human values, whereas the monster he has created becomes more human, highlighting the contrast.

    4. Characterization of the Protagonist in Horror

    4.1 Weakness / Need and the «Ghost»

    A fundamental element connected to the weakness/need dynamic is the ghost: a traumatic event from the past that creates the hero's weakness. In horror cinema, this element is crucial. It often takes the following forms:

    A sin from the past, committed by the hero, their parents, or even society as a whole (original sin, tacit agreement, collective wrongdoing).

    This sin becomes a taboo, something that remains unspoken.

    The taboo establishes a moral boundary between humans and monsters: cannibalism; deviant sexual impulses (incest, rape…); extreme violence; etc.

    As long as this sin remains unaddressed, it creates a moral debt. Psychologically, this debt manifests itself as shame: the hero's mind then turns against itself.

    Examples:

    • «I Know What You Did Last Summer»: a past crime comes back to haunt the characters (literally).
    • «A Nightmare on Elm Street»: the parents burned Freddy, who returns in their children's dreams — a transgenerational sin.

    4.2 Human / Monstrous Duality

    The character's weakness often lies in being trapped within an inherited system of beliefs. They must learn to break free from it.

    The struggle is no longer merely physical, but moral: the hero is torn between their human side and their monstrous side.

    To embody this duality, horror frequently uses the antagonist as a personification of the hero's fears, often in the form of a symbolic or literal double («Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde»).

    In «Frankenstein», for example, the man who seeks to overcome death gradually loses his humanity, while the monster gains it. One character's trajectory descends as the other's rises, illustrating the gradual shift in their respective degrees of humanity.

    5. The Shining & Kubrick

    When the genre is pushed to its extremes, as in «The Shining», this reflection extends to humanity as a whole, including from a societal perspective.

    Kubrick almost always refused to explain the meaning behind his films, but he nevertheless stated the following about «The Shining»:

    «There is something inherently wrong with human nature. There is an evil side to it. One of the functions of horror stories is to show us the archetypes of the unconscious; they allow us to see the dark side without having to confront it directly.»

    And so, the theme he explores is the following:

    «Can humanity evolve (overcome its evil side), or is it doomed to destroy itself because of a broken mind?»

    6. His Method

    Kubrick liked to conceal his message and invite the viewer to reflect:

    «If you really want to communicate something, even if it's just an emotion or an attitude, let alone an idea, the least effective and least enjoyable way is to be direct. It only touches people superficially. But if you can get people to think for a moment about what you're trying to say, and then discover it for themselves, the pleasure of discovery goes straight to the heart.»

    To achieve this, he uses several techniques:

    • symbols hidden within the sets
    • wide-shot compositions that make full use of space
    • cinematic language as a means of conveying meaning
    • visual and narrative echoes between scenes, like mirrors reflecting one another


    In «The Shining», he places particular emphasis on the manipulation of space and time, deliberately blurring the viewer's points of reference to create a sense of unease and guide them toward the film's underlying message.

    7. A Word of Caution

    «The Shining» is an extensively analyzed film, and interpretations of it are numerous. My analysis is particularly inspired by the work of Rob Ager, whose research has often confirmed certain ideas I had identified myself.

    However, this remains a personal interpretation. I consistently try to connect the film's message to the character's narrative arc, without claiming to offer an absolute truth.

    Given the darkness of the theme and the complexity of the film, I will outline here the main line of interpretation we will follow:

    The transgenerational nature of trauma, explored through Jack's internal struggle to avoid descending into inhumanity, and, more broadly, an examination of violence at the societal level.

    Analysis

    00:00 – 10:35 — Exposition

    As explained earlier, Kubrick constructs «The Shining» by constantly creating connections between scenes. Certain details that may seem insignificant when they first appear will only reveal their meaning much later. It is therefore important to identify a few of them from the outset: Jack's green tie, the mention of the winter of 1970 and Charles Grady and his two daughters, aged eight and ten, or the shot of Danny in front of the mirror with the bear in the background.

    From the exposition, «The Shining» presents Jack Torrance as a struggling writer. He is unable to make a living from his writing and takes on various jobs to support himself while hoping to continue writing. This professional instability has a direct impact on his family life.

    We quickly meet his family: Wendy and their son Danny. Danny is portrayed as a lonely child, without friends, who has created an imaginary companion. This characteristic, combined with his introverted behavior, suggests an underlying emotional distress. The film implies that Jack's lifestyle (his professional failure, frustration, and rigidity) negatively affects the family's stability.

    From a structural perspective, this sequence clearly establishes the main character's weakness: Jack is unhappy, frustrated, and hurts those around him. He has found his place neither as a writer nor as a father. His need would therefore be to understand the source of his failure and, through this understanding, finally manage to write something meaningful: to find that «good story» he has been searching for.

    The inciting incident occurs during the interview at the Overlook Hotel, when Jack is told the story of a former caretaker who murdered his two daughters with an axe before committing suicide. This story represents a crime from the past, a central motif in horror cinema. It is all the more disturbing because it foreshadows almost exactly what will happen later in the film.

    But if we focus on Jack's narrative line as a writer, this story can also be interpreted as a creative trigger. Jack has just discovered a story «worth telling», one that mysteriously resonates with his own personal history. The film does not yet make this connection explicit, but it will gradually develop it.

    From this moment onward, we can therefore assume that Jack's desire emerges: to write this story, or at least draw inspiration from it. Kubrick will subsequently scatter various clues suggesting that Jack is indeed writing. This introduces an essential ambiguity: does what we see belong to Jack's reality, or to the fiction he is creating?

    This hypothesis opens up an important interpretation of the film: «The Shining» could also represent the creative process of a writer attempting to give shape to an idea and who, through fiction, gradually explores a deeply personal story that he does not yet understand.

    10:35 – 17:40 — Danny and the Psychiatrist

    This sequence introduces a first major clue suggesting that we may be entering Jack's fiction: the explicit appearance of the supernatural. Tony, Danny's double, possesses the ability to foresee events and shows him images of the future. The supernatural is therefore no longer merely suggested: it becomes a reality within the narrative. This opens up the possibility that we have entered a mental or fictional space constructed by Jack.

    The following scene, however, seems to bring us back to a form of reality. Jack calls Wendy to tell her that he has gotten the job at the Overlook and will be home late. If we remove this scene from the context of a horror film and forget what we know about what follows, his behavior is not yet particularly alarming. It is primarily our knowledge of what is going to happen, reinforced by Jack Nicholson's deliberately ambiguous performance, that leads us to perceive something disturbing in him already.

    Kubrick also seems to introduce a visual code involving the color green, which is regularly associated with Jack in scenes that could be considered part of reality. This subtle code might allow us to distinguish between different narrative levels without ever explicitly identifying them.

    Kubrick also plays with space and objects within the set. In the bathroom, the duck disappears and then reappears near the window. A Goofy puppet, dressed in a way that resembles Wendy, appears in the background. It may evoke the way Wendy adopts the behavior Jack expects of her, particularly when she justifies the violence he inflicted on Danny. These anomalies create a subtle feeling that something is «not quite right» within the image, without the film yet explaining why.

    At 12:44, another visual element appears: a bear, visible in the background while the doctor speaks to Danny. For now, the object seems insignificant, but it will reappear several times and gradually acquire a much more disturbing meaning, connected to violence, sexuality, and child abuse.

    If we now analyze this scene through the hypothesis of Jack's fiction, something begins to emerge beneath the narrative: Danny appears to be an abused child. The psychiatrist immediately senses something unusual when he talks about Tony. An imaginary friend can, of course, be part of a child's normal development, but in the interpretation proposed here, Tony could also represent a dissociative mechanism.

    When faced with trauma inflicted by someone who should represent safety and protection, a child encounters an extremely difficult contradiction to process. Dissociation can then allow the child to separate certain experiences or emotions from conscious awareness. Tony can be interpreted as the fictional embodiment of this mechanism.

    An important question remains: what exactly is the nature of the violence Danny has experienced? The film provides one explicit piece of information: Jack has already physically abused his son, even dislocating his shoulder. But I believe Kubrick gradually hints at something more serious: the possibility of sexual abuse.

    At this stage of the film, he never states this directly. Instead, he constructs a network of clues whose significance only becomes apparent in retrospect. When the psychiatrist questions Danny about Tony, some of her questions take on a disturbing dimension within this interpretation. Tony is a little boy who «lives in his mouth». When she asks Danny whether Tony sometimes tells him to do certain things, Danny withdraws and refuses to talk about him any further.

    Taken individually, these elements prove nothing. But when placed within the network of motifs Kubrick develops later, they create a subtext surrounding the body, sexuality, and a trauma that Danny is unable to verbalize. The bear motif, associated with Danny and his bed, will return until the sexual appearance of the man dressed as a bear near the end of the film. Another clue will appear when Jack reads an issue of Playgirl: the cover notably refers to incest between parents and children.

    Within this interpretation, Tony takes on a more precise meaning. Faced with a trauma that is impossible to process, Danny may have created another identity capable of carrying what he himself cannot confront or describe. The Shining then transforms this psychological mechanism into a supernatural power: fiction gives a fantastical form to something profoundly real.

    The psychiatrist attempts to understand the nature of the relationship between Danny and Tony, but despite the disturbing signs, she ultimately downplays the situation. Wendy explicitly recounts that Jack has already been violent toward Danny, while immediately accompanying her account with a carefully constructed justification. Despite this, the doctor concludes that there is no real reason for concern.

    The scene therefore highlights a more silent social crime: failing to see, failing to name, and failing to intervene. Violence does not perpetuate itself solely because an individual is violent. It can also continue because those around them, and society more broadly, find ways to avoid confronting what is really happening.

    Conclusion

    We can now return to Kubrick's statement quoted at the beginning of the analysis: «There is something inherently wrong with human nature. There is an evil side to it. One of the functions of horror stories is to show us the archetypes of the unconscious; they allow us to see the dark side without having to confront it directly.»

    If our hypothesis is correct, Jack the writer uses the horror story precisely to confront his own dark side indirectly. He invents Danny, Tony, the Shining, the Overlook, and its ghosts. He transforms his trauma into a supernatural narrative. But through this fiction, something he had buried deep within himself gradually begins to resurface.

    Fiction reflects an unconscious truth. Perhaps this is, ultimately, Jack's true Shining: his ability as an artist to bring forth a truth that he is not yet capable of expressing directly. Danny would then represent the part of Jack that is capable of seeing.

    Unlike the monstrous Jack within his story, Danny manages to confront the trauma, understand the violence that has been passed down to him, and escape the labyrinth. Through the act of creation, Jack the writer might therefore symbolically achieve what his fictional counterpart fails to accomplish: freeing himself from the evil he has inherited.

    We can now return to the question raised at the beginning: «Can humanity evolve — overcome its evil side — or is it doomed to destroy itself because of a broken mind?» On an individual level, «The Shining» seems to offer a relatively positive answer: yes, an individual can break the cycle of transmission. But doing so requires confronting the past, accepting the trauma, and recognizing violence for what it truly is.

    Jack, within the fiction, fails. Danny succeeds. And if Danny is a projection of Jack as a child, then Jack the writer may also have achieved something through the writing of this story.

    However, the film does not truly provide a resolution on a societal level. Historical violence remains present within the Overlook. The photograph remains. The hotel remains. The collective cycle is therefore not clearly broken.

    In fact, an important structural stage is missing: the new equilibrium. Kubrick does not show us Jack Torrance after this experience. We do not see the writer finish his novel, publish it, and finally achieve success. Such a resolution would probably be far too explicit.

    But perhaps he leaves us one final clue. If we listen to the end credits all the way through, we can hear applause. We might then imagine one final possibility: the film we have just watched is actually the story that Jack Torrance finally managed to write. After spending the entire narrative searching for his «good story», he has finally found it. The applause would then represent, very subtly, his new equilibrium: Jack has finally become a writer.

    Back to top